Introduction: The Hobby Before 1989

Let’s set the scene. In 1989, baseball card collecting was already booming. Kids were ripping wax packs of Topps, Fleer, and Donruss, building sets with gum-stained fingers, and trading “commons” on the playground like a second currency. The hobby was fun, affordable, and… a little stale.

Topps, Fleer, and Donruss had cornered the market, but the cards themselves? Flimsy cardstock. Printing quality? Meh. Counterfeits? Everywhere. Junk wax? Oh, it was already in the oven, baking to perfection.

Enter Upper Deck, a new company that promised to blow the roof off the hobby with high-quality photography, premium cardstock, anti-counterfeit holograms, and — oh yeah — a certain rookie card that would become the face of modern collecting.

Spoiler alert: the 1989 Upper Deck Ken Griffey Jr. #1 is the Mona Lisa of modern baseball cards.

The Birth of Upper Deck

Upper Deck wasn’t founded by lifelong collectors; it was created by a group of entrepreneurs, including Bill Hemrick and Paul Sumner, with one mission: elevate sports cards from kids’ toys to serious collectibles.

Their idea was radical at the time:

  • Thicker, white cardstock instead of cheap gray.

  • Full-bleed photography that looked more like posters than cards.

  • A hologram on the back to prevent counterfeiting.

  • Glossy coating that made the cards feel like luxury items.

And perhaps the biggest flex of all? They didn’t even start their checklist with a veteran. They put a rookie, Ken Griffey Jr., right at #1. That wasn’t just a card placement — it was a statement.

The Checklist (700 Cards + High Numbers)

The 1989 Upper Deck Baseball set is split into two series:

  • Low numbers (#1–700)

  • High numbers (#701–800, short-printed and tougher to find)

The checklist was loaded with stars, Hall of Famers, and rookies. Let’s break down some of the most notable names.

Rookies:

  • Ken Griffey Jr. (#1) — The card that launched a thousand collections.

  • Randy Johnson (#25) — The “Big Unit,” complete with a Marlboro sign photo variation.

  • Gary Sheffield (#13) — He of the waggle.

  • John Smoltz (#17) — Before he was in the Hall of Fame and the broadcast booth.

  • Craig Biggio (#273) — Catcher-turned-second-baseman and Hall of Famer.

  • Jerome Walton (#668) — Okay, not a Hall of Famer, but hot in 1989.

Stars and Hall of Famers:

  • Cal Ripken Jr. (#24)

  • Nolan Ryan (#145, #774) — With two cards, because of course.

  • Bo Jackson (#275) — Peak Bo Knows era.

  • Jose Canseco (#371) — Still riding the Bash Brothers hype.

  • Mike Schmidt (#15) — Final career cards.

  • Ozzie Smith, Wade Boggs, Tony Gwynn, Roger Clemens, Kirby Puckett, Mark McGwire, Don Mattingly — All the 80s icons are here.

High Number Series:

The high numbers gave collectors some extra star power and late-season rookies. Nolan Ryan’s #774 Texas Rangers card is among the most famous in the update.

Ken Griffey Jr. #1: The Crown Jewel

No single card has defined a modern era like Griffey’s rookie.

Why is it iconic?

  1. Perfect timing: Griffey was hyped as “The Kid,” the smiling, smooth-swinging son of a big leaguer with talent dripping out of every at-bat.

  2. Card #1: The set literally began with him. Upper Deck knew what they were doing.

  3. Photography: That Mariners cap, that smile, that bat over the shoulder — it’s timeless.

  4. Mass production: Millions were printed, yet the card still holds value because of demand and nostalgia.

Griffey #1 is the Babe Ruth rookie of the modern era. If you collected in the late 80s/early 90s, odds are this card was your Holy Grail.

The Innovations That Changed Everything

Upper Deck didn’t just bring Griffey. They revolutionized the hobby:

  • Premium Cardstock: Compared to Donruss mush, these felt like credit cards.

  • Hologram Security: Each card back had a hologram, a first in the industry.

  • Photography: No more boring mugshots. Players were captured in action, smiling, and dynamic.

  • Packaging: Foil packs that made it harder to search and reseal.

These changes forced Topps, Fleer, and Donruss to raise their game. By the early 90s, the “premium card” era was in full swing, with Stadium Club, Fleer Ultra, and others following Upper Deck’s lead.

Historical Importance of the Set

Let’s be clear: 1989 Upper Deck is the line of demarcation in the hobby.

Before 1989 = cardboard, gum, and penny packs.
After 1989 = glossy, premium, investment-grade collectibles.

The set is historically important because:

  • It legitimized cards as investments, not just kids’ toys.

  • It launched Griffey’s legend, giving us the most famous modern rookie.

  • It sparked the “arms race” of the 90s, leading to insert mania, parallels, and eventually, today’s hit-driven products.

Collector Commentary (With Jokes)

  • Opening 1989 Upper Deck packs in 1989 felt like discovering fire. You’d pull out that thick, glossy card and think, “Are these even legal?”

  • The Griffey rookie was so hyped, kids swore they had five of them — but they were actually holding Randy Johnson. (Sorry, Big Unit.)

  • That Randy Johnson Marlboro sign variation? Proof that even the most serious rookies need a little smoke break.

  • The Jose Canseco card is peak late 80s hobby: tight uniform, mullet glory, and the smug look of a man who hit 40-40.

  • The foil packs were cool, but also annoying. Every kid with braces accidentally ripped open three cards trying to open one pack.

Market Values Today

So how do the key cards hold up?

  • Ken Griffey Jr. #1: Raw copies are common, but PSA 10s can fetch thousands. In 2021’s boom, they hit $5,000+. Today, they’re closer to $1,500–$2,500.

  • Randy Johnson #25: PSA 10 hovers in the $200–$300 range, with variation cards worth more.

  • Gary Sheffield, John Smoltz, Craig Biggio rookies: Solid, but not Griffey level. PSA 10s in the $50–$150 range.

  • Nolan Ryan #774 (High Number): A collector favorite, with PSA 10s fetching $250+.

Griffey remains the prize, but the set as a whole is beloved by collectors.

The Legacy

The legacy of 1989 Upper Deck can be summed up in one word: revolutionary.

  • It changed the way cards were made.

  • It cemented Griffey as a hobby icon.

  • It set the tone for the 90s boom — both the glory and the eventual overproduction bust.

Even today, if you show a Griffey rookie to a non-collector, they know it. That smile is hobby shorthand for an entire era.

Final Thoughts

The 1989 Upper Deck set is more than cardboard. It’s a cultural artifact. It’s the set that dragged the hobby into the modern age, for better or worse.

If you were a collector back then, you remember chasing Griffey like it was buried treasure. If you’re new, owning a Griffey rookie is practically a rite of passage.

Yes, millions were printed. Yes, it fueled overproduction. But without 1989 Upper Deck, the hobby as we know it wouldn’t exist.

And let’s be honest — if you don’t get at least a little smile when you see that Griffey Jr. #1, you might want to check your pulse.

Posted in Articles, Checklists and tagged , , , , , , , , , ,