In 2024, GameStop has started a new program where they buy PSA-graded sports and gaming cards, including Pokémon cards. They accept only cards with a PSA grade of 8 or higher, and the cards must have the Lighthouse label for authenticity. The maximum value for a single card they will accept is $500, and the value offered for the cards can be taken as cash or in-store credit, with the store credit option providing a higher return (40% more) than cash​ (Sports Collectors Daily)​​ (Hobby Listings)​​ (CollectShop)​.

This initiative is part of GameStop's broader strategy to diversify its offerings and tap into the growing collectibles market. Currently, the program is available in selected states, including Connecticut, Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi, New York, Tennessee, and Texas, with plans to expand further​ (Sports Collectors Daily)​​ (ComicBook)​.